I'm looking for two or three writers to join the Five Cantonas team. Three or four posts a week. Intelligent and realistic. Drop me a line; redben at fivecantonas dot com

Ferguson’s Double Standards Could Hurt David De Gea’s Progress

One of the better things to come from the end of last season was the establishment of David De Gea, not just as our first choice goalkeeper, but as one of the top goalkeepers in the Premier League, certainly from January onwards. After a nervous start when was rightly blamed for a few mistakes, he found the finger wrongly pointing towards him after almost every single goal conceded by Manchester United. Free header six yards out? The keeper should be claiming that. Unstoppable strike from the edge of the area? Edwin would have saved that.

Despite such negativity, he was able to hold his head high by the end of the season with saves such as the one from Mata in the 90th minute at Stamford Bridge worth points on their own. His form continued into the new season, his outstanding shot-stopping ability being one of the main reasons we escaped Old Trafford with all three points last weekend. Unfortunately, Ferguson decided that the keeper’s role in one of the goals that we did concede warranted being dropped, having decided that De Gea was reckless in coming for the cross that ended up bouncing in of Nemanja Vidic.

I think young David made a mistake last week. He knows it. With the form he’s been in, he’s been making some fantastic saves but one error like that could have cost us the game. It’s just a learning process for him and he’ll be back in a couple of weeks after the international break. ‘Anders had his first game. I thought he was a little bit nervous at points but he’s a very good keeper also. I don’t think it’s a big issue but it’s something you have to deal with.

I know it’s completely taboo to criticise Sir Alex Ferguson in any way, but this really is a horrific way to handle the goalkeeper. It could damage his confidence in the short term and make him scared of mistakes in the long term. It sends completely the wrong message; the message that no matter how well you play it is your mistakes that will be remembered and influence the manager’s decision making.

I’m not even going to go into the apportioning blame game here, because I still don’t think De Gea was totally at fault for the goal. I feel he’s fouled by the Fulham player who clearly jumps towards him, and not towards the ball, when the cross comes over. Vidic misses his header too but, no, De Gea finds himself lumbered with the blame as is disproportionately often the case. So, for the purposes of this discussion, let’s assume we are all in agreement that it was completely David’s fault.

How, then, will he be feeling when Robin van Persie lines up for Manchester United after the international break? By Fergie’s own definition, RvP made an “error that could have cost us the game”. RvP also won us the game with his individual performance, something that Dave did against Fulham. What are we doing with Van Persie? Are we dropping him because of the mistake that could have cost us the game, or are we keeping him in the side because his overall performance contributed to our win? What’s it gonna be, Fergie? You can’t have it both ways.

If you’re doing to drop one player for making an honest mistake during an otherwise outstanding performance, are you going to keep another player in the side after making a stupid mistake in a similar scenario? If so, what’s the difference? Why is one punished but not the other?

I’m not calling for Robin van Persie to be dropped. That would be utterly dead-brained. What I’m doing is pointing out how strange the decision to drop Dave was, and how potentially damaging it could be. Such victimization, if you can call it that, is how players end up not seeing eye-to-eye with the manager. Dave will have sat there, saw Van Persie fuck his penalty right up, and felt a strange sense of deja vu.  I’m not sure he’ll feel the same when the next team sheet goes up.

That would be a terrible shame, given what we know about all of the Manchester United players who don’t see eye-to-eye with Sir Alex. Or, should I say, ex-Manchester United players…

One Response to “Ferguson’s Double Standards Could Hurt David De Gea’s Progress”

  • Bobby Charlton's combover:

    I agree. I was surprised he was dropped because of that mistake. If we take that as the yardstick we wouldn’t have more than 3 or 4 players to pick from for any game. Evra would only play every second game.

Leave a Reply

FiveCantonas Twitter

Follow @FiveCantonas
Polls

Michael Carrick, Yaya Toure, Ramires or Moussa Dembele?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
Categories
Archives
Manchester United News & Transfers
  • silverlight downloaden mac gratis
  • vcl player downloaden free
  • album unheilig kostenlos downloaden
  • gothic 2 kostenlos downloaden vollversion deutsch
  • klassiek lettertype downloaden
  • tsuka's furni pack downloaden
  • mit youtube musik downloaden
  • sony drivers download
  • youtube filmpje downloaden mp3
  • gratis mp3 beltonen downloaden
  • windows live messenger downloaden oude
  • van youtube downloaden naar ipod
  • saw 1 kostenlos downloaden deutsch
  • nero gratis downloaden nederlands vista
  • zip file downloaden
  • htc sync manager download
  • vuze sneller laten downloaden
  • metin2 9 hack downloaden
  • kostenlos downloaden java
  • downloaden programma voor muziek
  • just dance gratis downloaden
  • legaal disney films downloaden
  • frostwire kostenlos downloaden chip
  • sony vegas downloaden gratis
  • weihnachtskarten zum downloaden freeware
  • fifa 11 downloaden full game
  • apps downloaden gratis zonder creditcard
  • downloaden virus
  • sims 3 downloaden op computer
  • film downloaden rundskop
  • programma zip downloaden
  • office programm downloaden kostenlos
  • download zip bestand
  • glee songs downloaden
  • nieuwste cd s downloaden
  • project blackout gratis downloaden
  • gta 5 demo downloaden
  • zune downloaden chip
  • films downloaden windows 7
  • picasa downloaden ipad
  • ballerspiele kostenlos downloaden vollversion
  • kostenlos stronghold 2 vollversion downloaden
  • app zum musik downloaden kostenlos
  • spiele für windows 7 downloaden
  • firefox 7 zum downloaden
  • emule gratis downloaden
  • rollercoaster kostenlos downloaden vollversion
  • free downloaden van dvd shrink 3.2
  • eenvoudig powerpoint downloaden
  • lernwerkstatt 7 kostenlos downloaden vollversion chip
  • google play downloaden mislukt
  • recorder programm downloaden
  • final fantasy 7 downloaden
  • games downloaden samsung chat 335
  • watch app downloaden gratis
  • download youtube
  • youtube filmpje downloaden ubuntu
  • blackberry app world downloaden bold 9000
  • huizen downloaden voor sims 3
  • word 07 kostenlos downloaden
  • antivir kostenlos downloaden vollversion chip 64 bit
  • macromedia flash gratis downloaden
  • photoshop hintergründe downloaden
  • link downloaden safari
  • twitter op blackberry downloaden
  • downloaden fotoshop gratis
  • app downloaden zonder play store
  • mozilla firefox 3.9 downloaden
  • video downloaden prosieben
  • iphone 3 firmware downloaden
  • just dance kostenlos downloaden
  • 9427679818
  • gratis downloaden mozilla firefox
  • perfect world deutsch downloaden 2010
  • windows 7 downloaden gratis nederlands
  • patch blocker ps3 downloaden
  • radio funx downloaden
  • saw 6 kostenlos downloaden deutsch
  • per cmd datei downloaden
  • pokemon pearl downloaden met cheats
  • htc magic update downloaden
  • skype downloaden voor windows 7
  • youcam gratis downloaden windows 7
  • gta city downloaden
  • limewire 7.0 gratis downloaden
  • photoshop download for mac
  • formulier zorgtoeslag 2010 downloaden
  • blackberry ping chat downloaden
  • youtube lieder downloaden firefox addon
  • spotify downloaden zonder facebook
  • gratis ebook downloaden herman koch
  • ps3 spiele schneller downloaden
  • gratis whatsapp download iphone 4s
  • games downloaden nintendo ds gratis
  • lieder downloaden von myspace
  • pc spiele legal downloaden
  • black jack zum downloaden
  • veilig downloaden van youtube
  • software downloaden ds
  • xbox 360 spiele downloaden kostenlos
  • nero express gratis downloaden nederlands
  • leuke lettertypes downloaden gratis
  • msn messenger 2009 downloaden kostenlos
  • video downloaden met android
  • apps downloaden philips tv
  • free studio manager downloaden mac
  • download games psp
  • microsoft visual basic downloaden
  • msn op mobile downloaden
  • super mario kostenlos downloaden deutsch
  • antivir kostenlos downloaden vollversion 2012
  • messenger plus downloaden chip
  • skype 5 0 kostenlos downloaden
  • films apple tv downloaden
  • downloaden excel sjablonen
  • firefox 4 downloaden voor mac
  • minecraft downloaden gratis 1.2.5
  • mac os x lion downloaden
  • hypercam 2 kostenlos downloaden deutsch
  • nero gratis downloaden nederlandse versie
  • antivirus downloaden kostenlos
  • nds spellen downloaden hoe
  • roms downloaden 3ds
  • 100 gratis films downloaden
  • updates downloaden samsung galaxy
  • open office word downloaden
  • pokemon toren verdedigen downloaden
  • films downloaden gratis spotnet
  • belastingaangifte downloaden 2008
  • call of bieber downloaden
  • das rettungsteam kostenlos downloaden
  • waar xbox spellen downloaden
  • navi software zum downloaden
  • battlefield heroes kostenlos downloaden
  • kostenlos 3gp converter downloaden
  • flash player downloaden voor blackberry
  • deluxe snake kostenlos downloaden
  • spelletjes downloaden voor je mobiel
  • teamviewer 7 downloaden kostenlos
  • itunes nieuwe downloaden
  • powerpoint thema's downloaden mac
  • zumba zum downloaden
  • messenger downloaden op gsm
  • belastingdienst downloaden formulieren
  • hoe muziek downloaden van youtube
  • muziek mix programma downloaden gratis
  • laatste itunes downloaden
  • neueste directx version downloaden
  • web filmpjes downloaden
  • winrar programm kostenlos downloaden
  • viber downloaden htc
  • whatsapp downloaden kon niet worden voltooid
  • adventure maps downloaden minecraft
  • city life downloaden
  • kostenlos mozilla firefox downloaden chip
  • pdf creator downloaden adobe
  • minecraft pokeball mod downloaden
  • djumbo liedjes downloaden
  • costa tv serie downloaden
  • gratis downloaden imesh
  • microsoft office outlook downloaden gratis
  • directx 9.0c gratis downloaden
  • liedje downloaden spotify
  • arte.tv downloaden videos
  • hyves downloaden op je mobiel
  • new kids movie downloaden
  • youtube downloader hd online
  • worms 2 kostenlos downloaden
  • browser mozilla firefox downloaden
  • htc wildfire blijft downloaden
  • java downloaden kostenlos deutsch
  • battlefield kostenlos legal downloaden
  • warrock kostenlos downloaden chip
  • serie downloaden met ondertiteling
  • puzzle express kostenlos downloaden
  • wordfeud downloaden ipad
  • gratis downloaden top 1000 aller tijden
  • ts3 bei chip downloaden
  • whatsapp downloaden op nokia
  • mario spellen downloaden
  • 4340451650
  • black ops update downloaden
  • games downloaden per lastschrift \/
  • nokia 5230 spelletjes downloaden
  • visual dj kostenlos downloaden chip
  • downloaden acrobat reader 9 gratis
  • paint downloaden 2012
  • hoe spellen downloaden wii
  • pokemon black downloaden op pc
  • limewire downloaden betaald
  • fifa 2010 downloaden voor pc
  • market downloaden op bb
  • per php datei downloaden
  • zdf mediathek downloaden linux
  • daemon tool kostenlos downloaden
  • metin2 neue items downloaden
  • nintendo 3ds spiele downloaden kostenlos
  • 132332500
  • adobe pdf freeware downloaden
  • mario spelletjes downloaden nds
  • sims downloaden voor mac
  • foto bearbeiten zum downloaden
  • problemen downloaden zylom
  • google maps kaarten downloaden htc
  • ebook downloaden bol.com
  • android 4 downloaden galaxy s2
  • divx player downloaden gratis
  • realplayer kostenlos downloaden deutsch
  • paint downloaden mac
  • ios 5 downloaden op iphone
  • mp3 downloaden met android
  • metin2 richtig downloaden
  • mods downloaden gta san andreas ps2
  • kostenlos atlantis quest downloaden
  • usb loader wii download
  • fifa 11 downloads kostenlos
  • downloads windows live movie maker
  • downloaden nieuwste films
  • sims 3 downloaden free nederlands
  • ipod 3 spiele kostenlos downloaden
  • boeken downloaden naar ipad
  • sims 3 vollversion downloaden kostenlos
  • uit het oog downloaden
  • htc wildfire musik downloaden
  • office 2003 download
  • gratis kinderboeken downloaden ipad
  • wimmelbildspiele vollversion downloaden gratis
  • games downloaden psp go
  • antivir webguard downloaden
  • explorer voor mac downloaden
  • mozilla thunderbird gratis downloaden
  • adobe photoshop downloaden windows 7
  • download adobe reader gratis
  • downloaden photoscape
  • apps downloaden computer
  • oude messenger downloaden
  • muziek ipod downloaden gratis
  • liedjes downloaden mp3 speler
  • lame codec downloaden
  • microsoft internet explorer downloaden
  • left 4 dead maps downloaden
  • downfish skype downloaden
  • msn downloaden voor mac
  • apps downloaden wildfire
  • facebook op bb downloaden
  • ccleaner kostenlos downloaden bei chip
  • whatsapp downloaden op ipod
  • downloaden faststone image viewer windows 7
  • halo kostenlos downloaden vollversion
  • siedler 1 gratis downloaden
  • ping downloaden curve
  • 100 bilder downloaden
  • cod4 zombie mod downloaden
  • google earth downloaden gratis 2012
  • tv movie zum downloaden
  • hyves desktop downloaden mobiel
  • sims 2 huisdieren downloaden gratis
  • nero 6 vollversion downloaden
  • win xp downloaden kostenlos
  • win7 tools kostenlos downloaden
  • microsoft word 2007 downloaden nederlands gratis
  • fifa downloaden full version
  • downloaden blackberry app world
  • typ top downloaden gratis
  • minecraft.rar kostenlos downloaden
  • google sketchup downloaden gratis nederlands
  • whatsapp voor samsung downloaden
  • word feud downloaden zonder android market
  • 1 euro film downloaden
  • realplayer downloaden voor mobiel
  • youtube videos downloaden ohne programm
  • ringtones downloaden voor android
  • gratis earth explorer downloaden
  • twitter voor blackberry downloaden
  • programma downloaden youtube naar mp3
  • adobe cs5 downloaden
  • american pie kostenlos downloaden deutsch
  • sims downloaden voor pc
  • downloaden kostenlos von youtube
  • bold theme downloaden
  • qip auf deutsch downloaden
  • uitleg downloaden via nieuwsgroepen
  • gratis nero 10 downloaden voor vista
  • wbfs manager downloaden gratis
  • fl studio downloaden free full
  • gratis microsoft office downloaden 2007
  • gratis ringtones downloaden new kids
  • film cars 2 downloaden
  • downloaden limewire
  • kostenlos musik downloaden legal ohne anmeldung
  • filme downloaden mit jdownloader
  • linux nederlands downloaden
  • kostenlos final fantasy 8 downloaden
  • just a dream downloaden
  • 24 seizoen 8 downloaden
  • mp3 downloaden programma
  • pokemon downloaden voor htc
  • msn 8.0 downloaden gratis nederlands
  • mix programma gratis downloaden
  • gratis downloaden windows vista
  • antivirus kostenlos downloaden avast
  • live essentials download
  • google chrome downloaden chip
  • microsoft office gratis downloaden 2010 nederlands
  • waar nds games downloaden
  • avast programm kostenlos downloaden
  • fifa 8 download
  • illegaal downloaden informatie
  • jailbreak spellen downloaden
  • laatste ps3 update downloaden
  • msn downloaden for blackberry
  • brandweer simulator downloaden gratis
  • yeti sport kostenlos downloaden
  • legal downloaden bei youtube
  • teamviewer 6 downloaden gratis
  • rabo mobiel downloaden
  • hyves downloaden voor nokia n97
  • virus downloaden zum verschicken
  • flash animation zum downloaden
  • youtube filmpjes downloaden windows media player
  • gratis ringtones downloaden voor blackberry
  • kostenlos lkw simulator downloaden vollversion
  • gratis mp3 downloaden waar
  • adobe pdf downloaden gratis